Hooker er asked to be relieved from duty, saying: "Justice and self-respect alike require my re- moval from an army in which rank and service are ignored" (War of the Rebellion:, Official Rec- ords, Army, I ser., XXXVIII, pt. 5, p. 273). Thus ended Joseph Hooker's military service in the field. In September 1864, he was transferred to command the Northern Department at Cin- cinnati, Ohio, where in 1865, after the eventful days of his life had passed, he married Olivia Groesbeck. On July 8, 1865, he was placed in command of the Department of the East at New York City; and on Aug. 23,1866, of the Depart- ment of the Lakes at Detroit. In 1868 his wife died, and on Oct. 15 of the same year he was re- tired as a major-general on account of paralysis. He died at Garden City, N. Y., and was buried beside his wife in Laurel Grove Cemetery, Cin- cinnati. Gossip has sometimes connected Hooker's name with questionable personal conduct which his friends and close associates stoutly dis- claimed. All authorities agree that he was ex- cellent as a corps commander. [G. W. Cullum, Biog. Reg. of the Officers and Grads. of the U. S. Mil. Acad. Card ed., 1891); G. A. Taylor, in Jour, of the Mil Service Inst. of the U. S., Sept- Oct 1910; War of the Rebellion: Official Records (Army), see index; "Report of the Joint Committee on the Conduct of the War/' Senate Report No. 142, 38 Cong., 2 Sess.; J. W. De Peyster, Obits, of Maj.-Gen. Samuel P. Heintselman and Maj.-Gen. Jos. Hooker (1881); John Bigelow, Jr., The Campaign of Chancel- lorsyille (1910) ; W. R. Livermore, The Story of the Civil War, pt. Ill (1913) ; Battles and Leaders of the Civil War (4 vols., 1887-88); Wm. Swinton, Cam- paigns of the Army of the Potomac (1866); J. H. Stine, Hist, of the Army of the Potomac (1892); T. A. Dodge, The Campaign of Chancellorsville (1881); Abner Doubleday, Chancellorsville and Gettysburg (1882) ; Geo. Meade, Life and Letters of George Gor- don Meade (2 vols., 1913); Autobiog. of Oliver Otis Howard (1907), vol. I; Memoirs of Gen. Wm. T. Sher- man (1875), vol. II; J. L. Butterfield, A Biog. Memorial of Gen. Daniel Butterfield (1904); H. E. Tremaine, Two Days of War (1905); Col. Alexander K. Me- Clure's Recollections of Half a Century (1902) ; Em- ory Upton, The Military Policy of the U. S. (1904) ; W. A. Ganoe, Hist, of the^ U. S. Army (1924); Daniel E. Sickles, Address Delivered in Boston before the Hooker Monument Asso. of Mass. (1910); Army and Navy Jour., Nov. 8, 1879; N. 7. Tribune, Nov. i, I879-] W.A.G. HOOKER, PHILIP (Oct. 28, i766-Jan. 31, 1836), builder, architect, surveyor, was the eld- est child of Samuel and Rachel (Hinds) Hooker and the great-grandson of Henry and Elizabeth (Hilliard) Hooker, or Hocker, of Medfield, Mass. He was born in Rutland, near Worcester, Mass., but moved with his parents, probably soon after 1772, to Albany, N. Y. It is with the latter town that his name is generally associated. From May 2, 1796, almost until the day of his death forty years later he figured in the Albany records. He was seven times elected assessor Hooker for the fourth ward, received three appointments to the common council between 1818 and 1821, was city superintendent from 1821 to 1827, and city surveyor from 1819 to 1832. It was never- theless principally as an architect and builder that he made his local reputation. Between 1797 and 1830 he designed, and in some cases built, for Albany, at least six churches, the state Capi- tol, the City Hall, two municipal markets, two academies, and a theatre. Of these buildings only the Albany Academy remains (1931) substan- tially unaltered. The demand for new buildings for Albany, which developed soon after 1790, and which afforded Hooker the opportunity of an architectural career, was a result of the town's having suddenly become the capital of New York and the principal northern gateway to the West. When Hooker began to design buildings Albany was a Dutch frontier village; at his death it had been reconstructed, largely through his own ef- forts, into the semblance of a thriving, New Eng- land city. Outside of Albany Hooker's principal works were the second Union College building, Schenectady, the second building for the First Presbyterian Church of Utica, Hyde Hall, on Otsego Lake, and the steeple and front of the Hamilton College Chapel in Clinton, N. Y. Hooker probably received his practical train- ing from his father, but his knowledge of archi- tectural design seems to have been derived primarily from his study of the work of other American architects, notably Macbean (St. Paul's Chapel, New York), Manghi and McComb (City Hall, New York), and Bulfmch (Hollis Street Church, Boston). From these men his archi- tectural ancestry may be traced through the Eng- lish architects of the eighteenth and seventeenth centuries to Palladio and Brunelleschi. Much of his work was distinguished by its good propor- tion, by its combination of refinement and bold- ness in the detail, and by its successful definition of the principal masses. Its occasional incon- gruities of arrangement and apparent lack of resource were due no doubt to some extent to the architect's deficient education and natural limi- tations, but probably to a much greater extent to the impecuniosity of his clients and the impossi- bility of obtaining either adequate materials or competent workmen. The family name of Hook- er's first wife is not known. His second wife, to whom he was married in 1814, was Sarah Monk. He died at Albany without issue. [The principal sources of information regarding Hooker are the manuscript minutes and other manu- script records of the Albany common council, the manuscript records of the churches and institutions for which he designed buildings, and vouchers, receipts, and other papers in the New "York state comptroller's office. Particular references to these and other sources of in-